Truthy Tuesday- To Share or Not to Share: Online Presences

When it comes to our online presence or persona, how much do you share? And how do you connect with your people without overstepping their need for privacy or over-sharing about yourself?

I think as a society and as individuals we’re all still figuring out the “rules.” Some rules are really obvious, don’t post your social security number on facebook- there are many others privacy and safety concerns, norms basically, of what not to share, but when it comes to what to share it really varies by individual.

I’ll admit that I’m a pretty open book. I share more than some people do online, that’s for sure, but I don’t think I’m an over-sharer, at least online (now with a few cocktails that’s another story). I have never untagged a photo and I will almost always share with my friends about hard things that are going on with me. Maybe not to the extent that I might give full details if I’m in a bad place, but generally, what you see is what you get with me.

Why am I like that? I am naturally extroverted, and as a kid I remember my grandma burning pictures or cutting herself out of them. When she passed I had so few pictures of her and I wished she had saved more for us. So, I let my images lay. Other people might want to see that picture of me someday and it’s the truth so I am OK with it. Don’t get me wrong, I do hate a double chin shot, but you know what? Sometimes I have a double chin- that’s real, so that’s OK with me.

There are some things I don’t share: I don’t trash talk, discuss sex, and you’ll never find my mug in a ‘glamor shot’. I just want to be my real self without getting too weird about it.

Something I’ve been considering recently is how to respect the boundaries of others and their online presences, while still being able to be my mostly open self. I know where my line is, but what about other people? I might be fine with sharing whatever photo that is taken of me, but I cannot assume that everyone feels this way.

If you meet up with a friend, take a picture of them with a cocktail, then post it on Instagram and their user name is their business name- is that a problem? What if you mention their business in the post if you’re talking business? For some this would overstep and others would be flattered to have their businesses mentioned. Where is the line between you sharing moments of your life and another person’s right to privacy?

Photos are really a microcosm of what we can share online: a post, check-in or really anything we share, if it’s directly affecting another person or a group of people, I feel we should tease through these scenarios case by case, think about our impact on others and ask our friends about their privacy lines.

As we get more and more used to this new level of sharing that most of us have at our fingertips, I think the rules of these boundary lines will begin to become more clear. I for one, plan to continue to talk with friends to get a better sense of their boundaries, so that I can be a good friend and a respectful online citizen.

 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

And I’m the introvert- I can be really quiet at times, I keep a lot of my private thoughts private, but when there’s a pen in my hand, a keyboard under my fingers or the ear of someone I love and trust beside me- I spill. I’m an open book.

Which means, I actually feel I share a lot online- through my blog mostly, and right here- my desires and struggles, thoughts and experiences. I feel like I share a lot of the big stuff, the real stuff, the important stuff.

I feel comfortable enough to share that with the people closest to me, and with you blog readers, too! Maybe it’s because when it’s a space I’ve created, if you’re coming to it, I feel like I’m in the company of friends and can be as open as I would around people I know and trust.

Social media feels different to me tho- eventhough blogs are “out there”, they’re still mostly being read by people who want to read them. Facebook, twitter, instagram, etc seems much more exposed to me, more open to strangers, to spam followers, to at least a portion of people who don’t really know and/or care about your life, they’re just following to follow (probably just so you’ll follow back, cause all they care about are the numbers.)

It begins to feel like the equivalent of small talk to me or being at a big party full of casual acquaintances (both things I dislike in real life!) Instead of having a bunch of tiny conversations with a bunch of different people about the weather and where I went that day, I’d much rather have long, real conversations with just a few folks.

So I don’t share a lot of “what I’m up to” or the random thoughts and tid-bits during my days on social media. I notice the only time I naturally reach for twitter or instagram, is when I’m bored- which is a rarity- not when I’m out doing things, engaging and enjoying life. It doesn’t even occur to me to take a pic and instagram it when I’m actually doing something “instagrammable!”

But that’s my natural inclination because I’m a loner, kind of anti-social- I’m just not used to jumping to share the day-to-dayness of my life with others like that. I’m trying to focus on just living it.

That brings up a-whole-nother bag of conversation about the line between documenting your life, and doing things in life just so you have something to blog about, or share on facebook, or whatever…it’s such a strange dynamic.

I’m personally a little scared at the constant interaction between human and machine and I know that interaction is only going to get more and more entwined and confusing as we progress. So, for now, I’ll pry open my heart, dissect my brain and spill it out for you all to see online because I feel it’s valuable and that’s what I actually like sharing- my view from here, so to speak.

But the day-to-day ups and downs, conversations, experiences, whines and small joys- those are moments I tend not to share with the online world, moments I want to keep just for me- and I think that’s ok.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

How much of your private life do you share online- where’s the line for you?

Ever have a friend cross your line by posting something about you online that you didn’t feel comfortable sharing with the public?

Do you feel like you’re giving up some of your privacy just to participate in this crazy social media land, or do you like sharing on a more personal level? The constant connection?

Leave a comment below! Or post your thoughts on your own blog, or public facebook note, share the link in the comments and we’ll add it to this post above for everyone to check out!

8 Responses to Truthy Tuesday- To Share or Not to Share: Online Presences
  1. Jeovanna Perez
    June 12, 2012 | 10:59 am

    Hello girls!
    I feel more like Jena
    I don’t feel very comfortable sharing my personal life in social media like faceboo but I do share a liste bit more in my blog. I find it as a therapy. Even it’s “online”, I know I just have a few real follower I consider very close to me, and they’re interested about what I share.

    I know people that can’t do ANYTHING without posting it on their social media pages, they feel the need of the social approval.
    Sometimes I think they just do the things to show the world they’re cool.

    • The Maven Circle
      June 12, 2012 | 12:43 pm

      Hi Jeovanna! Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts!

      I know, I get curious about people who seem to post about almost everything on social media too, more because it’s so unlike me that I’m interested in how it seems natural for them to share so much! I think more “sociable” people maybe share more stuff like that online? I tend to mull things over in my head more than talk about them (from my only childness perhaps)- maybe quieter people in life are quieter online too?

      Very strange this internet land of ours- glad to have your voice here in the mix tho. Thanks for sharing! -jena

  2. Sophie
    June 12, 2012 | 4:39 pm

    I agree with Jeovanna. I think people share to get approval from the outside, to validate what they are doing. I slightly fell for that for a while and it became such a headache to worry about the response I would get!! It wasn’t for me. I want to share private thoughts privately, it feels more valuable and gratifying to me. I am more of a small group type of girl and can be quite the extrovert if I feel comfortable around these people but as a whole I am more of an introvert. Actually i just realized that quitting Facebook made me have to reconnect with the people i cared about in the “old fashioned” way, a personal email!
    Thanks for your thoughts as always Maven. We appreciate your sharing here!

    • The Maven Circle
      June 13, 2012 | 10:14 am

      Sophie, I think you are right, some people need to validate their lives with constant updates. I was starting to fall into this realm for awhile too, but recently asked myself about how much what I was posting mattered and I decided that I’d like to post less and share less in general, but what’s funny is my not posting that much to another person is posting all the time. Everyone’s perspective is a little different when it come to their own boundaries with online content. Thanks for sharing! – Jen

  3. Kerry
    June 13, 2012 | 5:48 am

    Wow! I struggle with how much I should be sharing all of the time. I have two kids and wonder if I should use their names and photos. Facebook is all friends and acquaintances so I use that as a place to keep in touch with people who do not live close. Twitter is a whole bunch of random people and I definitely not as quick to post there. The younger generation shares everything and the lack of privacy concerns me a bit. It is all so interesting.

    • The Maven Circle
      June 13, 2012 | 10:11 am

      I agree, Kerry. It’s all so interesting- what people choose to share or keep to themselves. We have a great Guest Maven post today. If you get a chance check it out! – Jen

  4. Coral
    June 13, 2012 | 10:37 pm

    I found this really hard when I first started my blog. I had been blogging my art for a few years under an alias, but I knew if I was going to start a “serious” blog, I was going to have to reveal my name. I have been blogging for about a year now, and I keep realizing that I am holding back and am worried that means people aren’t connecting with me. And I have been reserved in putting my blog out there. Not sure what I am scared off. But I keep taking steps to open up while still feeling comfortable about how much to share. And I get braver in what I am sharing on my blog, where I share my blog and reaching out to other bloggers, business people and mentors while still being comfortable with what I am sharing.

  5. AlyChap
    June 15, 2012 | 4:32 am

    Hi Mavens! This is a great topic.
    I have been struggling with my own blog for quite some time because I can never decide what is worth sharing, or if i feel comfortable sharing anything at all! It can be really stifling for an introvert like myself. On the one hand I worry about coming off as being completely self-absorbed, but on the other if I don’t share there will be no connection with readers. Such a struggle. I think I feel most comfortable sharing something that I think will be of value to others.

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?